The following news item is printed in its entirety as
it appeared in the New Haven Register,
February 22, 2006:
SUPER LAWYERS: This pair met their match in the
courtroom
February 22, 2006
- New Haven
Register
By Phil Helsel, Register Staff
NEW HAVEN — Three years out of graduate school, Tara
Knight began her law practice out of a small, cheap office
on Williams Street, overlooking the noisy train tracks that
occasionally interrupted her discussions with clients.
She didn’t have a secretary, a staff or even an
office computer. Her first case that went to trial was defending
a Derby man accused of brutally beating his girlfriend, almost
killing her, and Knight lost.
"It was upsetting, but I had cases that very next day," said
Knight, now a partner of Knight, Conway & Cerritelli
LLC in New Haven. "I went in the very next day to make sure
everyone knew that I wasn’t going to let it get me
down. It was devastating."
That was in 1997. This year, Connecticut Magazine named
her a "Super Lawyer" and her name is routinely mentioned
among the top criminal defense attorneys in the area. But
another "Super Lawyer" isn’t hard to find — she
married high-profile New Haven attorney, Hugh Keefe of Lynch,
Traub, Keefe and Errante, last year.
Keefe has been on the "who’s who" list of criminal
defense attorneys for years, having been exposed to the limelight
when he helped represent members of the Black Panthers in
the New Haven murder trial in the late ’60s.
So Keefe says the fact that he was listed as a "Super Lawyer" by
the magazine, which is owned by the New Haven Register’s
parent company, as well as being named as one of the five
best lawyers in the state in 1990 and again in 2001, is less
of a surprise or an accomplishment. Keefe said that his wife
deserves a greater level of respect because she rose to the
top in a male-dominated industry.
"The criminal trial lawyer bar has been virtually exclusively
male since its beginning," Keefe said. "She has broken into
the field and formed an exclusively criminal defense firm;
she’s the only woman to do that."
Keefe and Knight were engaged in December 2004 and they married
in September in Boston.
"She’s brilliant; she’s witty; she’s animated," Keefe
said. "She’s beautiful — what else is there?"
Both were previously married once, but divorced.
Keefe and Knight knew each other for years, but were first
thrown together professionally when they represented the
infamous former New London attorney Beth Carpenter, who was
convicted in 2002 of hiring a hit man to kill her brother-in-law
in East Lyme and sentenced to life in prison without the
possibility of parole.
Knight, a graduate of Fairfield University and later Suffolk
University in Boston, downplays the magazine’s designation — "There
are public defenders working in the pits every day, pulling
rabbits out of their hats," she says — but the recognition
doesn’t begin or end with her inclusion on the magazine’s
top-lawyer list.
She was elected by her peers to serve as president of the
Connecticut Criminal Defense Lawyers Association; she became
one of only two women criminal defense attorneys listed in
the "The Best Lawyers in America," a biennial publication
that bills itself as the preeminent referral guide to the
legal profession in the country, and was listed New York
Magazine’s "The New York Area’s Best Lawyers,
A Definitive Guide To Legal Representation in New York, New
Jersey and Connecticut."
Together, Knight and Keefe were part of a three-lawyer team
that forced the state to virtually throw out its cases against
Vietnamese immigrants Thu Dang, Tam Ha and Meng Le, who were
accused of growing and storing almost $4 million worth of
marijuana in their West Havem homes, because of suspect search-and-seizure
techniques used by police.
She also won an acquittal for Wilbert Howard of Ansonia last
month, who was accused along with his wife of embezzling
almost $400,000 from an elderly Seymour man as he lay stricken
with Parkinson’s disease last month.
But Knight says she still believes in the idealistic notions
that got her into criminal defense work in the first place:
that abuse of prosecutorial power is inexcusable, and that
every accused killer, thief or drug dealer has some redeeming
qualities.
"I’ve got a soft spot in my heart for underdogs," she
said. "Someone once said, ‘The good guys aren’t
so good and the bad guys aren’t so bad,’ and
I believe that."
Keefe said he tells his students at Yale Law School, where
he has taught trial practice for the last 20 years, that
young lawyers should worry less about the paycheck and more
about their reputations at first.
"Don’t worry about the money — money will take
care of itself," Keefe said. "The important thing is to create
a reputation. Do cases for nothing, or become a special public
defender … you get paid a pittance, but if you do
a good job, word will get around."
It also helps if you get a few breaks along the way. Keefe,
after serving a stint in the Army and being hired by the
firm where he now is a managing partner, was picked to be
local counsel in the Black Panther trial in New Haven. Several
members of the Black Panthers, including its chairman, Bobby
Seale, were accused of killing a police informant; Seale
was not convicted, but others involved reached plea agreements
sparing them long sentences.
"I was just a young kid, but I was local counsel for some
national attorneys," Keefe said. "I think that went a long
way towards kicking my career off."
But Knight said that the big names aren’t always the
most rewarding cases.
"The cases you’re most proud of are the ones that don’t
get a lot of attention," Knight said. "It’s the person
who’s got a drug problem that you’re able to
get them some help. It’s the little ones."