The
following news item is printed in its entirety as it appeared
in the New Haven Register,
February 1, 2006:
Man acquitted of cheating ailing senior
February 1, 2006
- New
Haven Register
By Phil Helsel, Register Staff
Prosecutors had alleged that Wilbert Howard helped his wife
cheat an 85-year-old Ansonia man with Parkinson’s disease
out of $500,000 while she worked for him as a home health aide,
cashing obviously forged checks and accepting thousands of
dollars to which he was not entitled.
But a Superior Court judge ruled Tuesday that the case against
Wilbert Howard was too weak to justify placing his fate in
the hands of a jury and acquitted him of all charges, prompting
Howard to burst into tears and weep uncontrollably.
As her husband put his head down on a table and sobbed after
the ruling, Linda Howard comforted him, saying, “Let
it out.” Wilbert Howard later declined to comment.
“I always thought this was a very thin case,”
said Wilbert Howard’s attorney, Tara
Knight of New Haven. “Unfortunately,
I think he got sucked into this mess. He had no idea what was
going on.”
But the case against Howard’s wife, 47, continues. She
is accused of using a rubber signature stamp to make out hundreds
of checks in David Seymour’s name, draining his bank
accounts of $491,491 and then shipping him off to Griffin Hospital
in Derby on a bogus medical emergency once his assets were
expended.
Seymour died penniless at the age of 85 on April 9, 2004,
about a year after Linda Howard allegedly sent him to the hospital
on a fake medical emergency and moved out of his apartment
on Westfield Road in Ansonia. Linda Howard is accused of spending
the stolen money on everything from Caribbean vacations to
her daughters’ tuition and a new porch for the couple’s
home.
Linda Howard is accused of stealing the lion’s share
of the money, but Deputy Assistant State’s Attorney Annemarie
Braun argued that Wilbert Howard also was culpable in the crime
because he deposited two checks made out to him for $7,000,
and he endorsed two allegedly fraudulent checks made out to
his wife in 2003, and couldn’t explain to investigators
what exactly the money was for.
But Judge Brian T. Fischer said that wasn’t enough to
meet the state’s burden of proof. He acquitted Wilbert
Howard, 56, just before 1 p.m. Tuesday of one count each of
first- and second-degree larceny and conspiracy to commit larceny.
“The only involvement is the four checks, and the issue
is not whether he could explain the checks,”
Fischer said. “The issue is the burden of the state to
prove (the charges).”
Michael Sullivan, an inspector for the chief state’s
attorney’s office in Rocky Hill, testified earlier that
Wilbert Howard admitted to depositing or endorsing the checks
but he didn’t seem to understand that depositing the
checks meant money would come out of Seymour’s account.
Knight said her client was “a simple man” who
suffers from learning disabilities and memory problems, and
that he was not a willing participant in any alleged criminal
scheme.
Meanwhile, attorneys representing Linda Howard called their
only witness and rested their case Tuesday afternoon. Dorothy
Bailey, who said she was friends both with Linda Howard and
Seymour, testified that when she cared for Seymour for nine
days in 2001 while Linda Howard was on a cruise, Seymour told
her that he considered her to be an “angel sent from
heaven” and would share his wealth with her.
“He said Mrs. (Linda) Howard was a godsend, an angel
sent from heaven for him,” Bailey said. “He said
there was nothing he wouldn’t do for Mrs. Howard and
her family.”
Linda Howard’s attorneys said they would make another
motion for acquittal Wednesday morning before closing arguments,
after failing to get the charges against her dropped Tuesday
afternoon. The focus this time will be whether Seymour told
family members that someone had taken his money without his
consent and whether Linda Howard made claims that she was in
control of Seymour’s finances prior to 2003.
If she isn’t acquitted, closing arguments will be made
Wednesday morning and the jury will begin deliberating. She
is charged with four counts of first-degree larceny, two counts
of second-degree larceny and conspiracy to commit first- and
second-degree larceny. She is free on $250,000 bail.